A first pass survey of how authoritative religious statements from within the Abrahamic religions engage (or not) with the Gradual Disempowerment (GD) threat.
Is Gradual Disempowerment on the Radar of the Abrahamic Religions?
Bottom Line
The world's religious traditions have started to make authoritative religious statements about advanced AI threats. We have read the authoritative religious statements we could find, and have asked a narrow question of them: to what extent does one specific concern, gradual human disempowerment (GD) in the sense defined by Kulveit et al.(2025), show up in them?
Kulveit et al. define GD as an impersonal drift-like process, distinct from both the deliberate misuse and autonomous misalignment scenarios, by which the three key societal systems of the economy, culture, and states could become gradually misaligned with human interests. GD is not driven by bad actors or the result of power concentration, but instead represents a ‘boiling the frog’ scenario which may result in a range of negative outcomes on a par with those which could result from the more familiar power concentration, deliberate misuse and autonomous misalignment scenarios.
In short, we did not find evidence that GD shows up strongly in these statements. Sometimes this is because the statements were more narrowly focussed on other threats and we should therefore not expect discussion of GD. Where it does show up – and it was most pronounced in some of the Orthodox sources and, more equivocally, in parts of the Catholic sources – we rarely find discussion of mechanisms by which GD may occur. Again, this is perhaps unsurprising, given the purposes of the statements. That said, the concept of GD seems to be present, at least in some of the sources, even where it is not explicitly articulated, and we predict that future statements of the Abrahamic religions on advanced AI threats may bring the concept more explicitly into focus.
However, GD passages were difficult to identify with confidence. This was mostly due to the fact that mentions of harmful developments rarely disambiguated between when these were driven by bad actors – this would make them a case of power concentration or deliberate misuse – and when they represent impersonal drift (GD developments in the proper sense). This meant that many passages admitted of multiple readings. On a final manual check, we also excluded a fairly large set of passages from the Catholic source Quo Vadis Humanitas concerning critiques of trans-/post-humanism which seemed to assume human steerage rather than drift. After this final check, GD extracts comprised only ~0.7% of the ~1790 passages we coded if we counted only those extracts which were unambiguously GD, and this rose to ~5% when we counted extracts which were plausibly interpreted as GD but also admitted of other readings. Either way, concern with GD appears marginal in this set of authoritative religious statements overall.
Note: we have restricted our analysis to the major Abrahamic religions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam).
Excluded
Dalai Lama's AI remarks via Mind & Life dialogues
Future of Life Institute Buddhist post (Hershock, 2025)
Future of Life Institute Hindu post (Chinmay Pandya, AWGP, 2024)
Public talks by Sadhguru
Public talks by Sri Sri Ravi Shankar
Level 1: Statements, addresses, speeches, multi-stakeholder charters, or broad ecumenical declarations that carry moral weight or directional guidance but lack binding juridical or magisterial enforcement
Level 2: Formal denominational resolutions, synodal motions, official rabbinical responsa, or state-linked institutional fatwas that establish normative or legal-religious standards for a specific community or jurisdiction.
Level 3: The highest tier of institutional law-making and doctrine within a tradition—such as Papal encyclicals (the highest exercise of Catholic ordinary magisterium) or binding international council resolutions (collective ijtihad by supreme jurists, like the OIC Fiqh Academy).